BackYard Chickens › Breeds & Supplies › Chicken Breeds › Welsummer › Welsummer Reviews

Welsummer Reviews

Ranked #14 in the category Chicken Breeds Write a Review
Community Rating (26 reviews)
Overall
Welsummer
April 23, 2012 at 12:02 pm
01ChickenGranny
Reviewed by 01ChickenGranny
Pros: Dark Brown Eggs, Good foragers, docile.
Cons: other chickens will pick on them

I love my welsummers.  They are really good hens and they lay beautiful dark brown eggs.  They are docile and other breeds have a tendency to pick on them in confinement.  Great foragers and lovely.

April 19, 2012 at 7:24 pm
faykokoWV
Reviewed by faykokoWV
Pros: dark eggs, quirky, good health
Cons: not super friendly

I got my Welsummers from a hatchery originally and I loved them.... until I saw the real thing!  I was lucky to do a swap for some great Welsummer stock from Nate Vanwey.  The difference between the breeder stock and the hatchery is amazing.

 

I love how pretty my girls are with their gold hackles and peachy colored breast feathers.  And the roos are soooo handsome and polite.

 

They do well without a lot of space, but they also enjoy free ranging.

January 11, 2012 at 6:46 pm
WoofMeowCluck
Reviewed by WoofMeowCluck
Pros: very pretty eggs

Bought my two when they were older. They were VERY easily spooked but still friendly and always in trouble, they got into everything!  I would have them again but only if I got them as day old chicks so they could be handled a lot. 

January 12, 2012 at 9:41 am
Neverland0330
Reviewed by Neverland0330
Pros: Great egg layers, calm
Cons: Easily spooked, runs from humans

I bought two welsummer hens and while they're very calm and nice, they do not like human contact. I bought them while they were about 7 months old so it could be because of the person who had them before me but no matter how much I hold them and take care of them, they still run from me. They're great egg layers though. They're also occasionally broody.

January 12, 2012 at 7:42 pm
juststruttin
Reviewed by juststruttin
Pros: Beautiful birds and eggs

Best dark brown layers of all the breeds I've tried and I think I've tried em all.  These guys are fantastic winter time layers and don't go broody.  Great birds.  Mine of are Whitmore Farm and I could not be happier with them.  

January 14, 2012 at 10:07 pm
tazcat70
Reviewed by tazcat70

Wonderful birds, nice egg color.  Not a lap chicken.

January 15, 2012 at 11:15 am
Montana-Hens
Reviewed by Montana-Hens
Pros: Dark Eggs
Cons: Flighty

I tried a Welsummer, not because this hen really met any of my criteria for a backyard flock in rural Montana but because this breed was known for eggs the color of terracotta.   I just had to try it.  Her eggs were beautiful, but she was a crummy layer compared to the others.   She was re-homed to a 4-Her who wanted to try the breed to show the bird and the eggs.   She was perfect for that.  As much fun as her dark eggs were, I am not sure that I would try one again.  She was flighty, had a big comb and her eggs didn’t come as often as I like.

 

She was a hatchery chick, and  really no surprises based on what was possible with the breed.  I just wanted those dark eggs, knowing full well I was choosing well outside of my criteria. 

January 18, 2012 at 7:23 am
EweSheep
Reviewed by EweSheep
Pros: Hardy, beautiful, good layers of terra cotta eggs, not flighy or nevous, gentle temperment
Cons: combs and wattles

Welsummers are one of my favorite breeds. All of mine are breeder/exhibition stock. No hatcheries. Dual purpose birds, excellent layers of terra cotta eggs, gentle disposition and temperment, beautiful plumage. Very hardy in winter despite of the roosters' wattles and combs being frostbitten but glad breeders are working on them to get them smaller, less chances of getting frostbitten. Tolerates summer heat well with high humidity when extra care is noted. Non broody breed but rare cases, they would brood and successfully raise chicks or will set eggs but will NOT raise chicks.

 

My Welsummers are very excellent layers, laying from end of January/beginning of Feb, all the way thru October before they molt. Fertility on these birds are pretty high, ranging from 95 to 100 percent in three batches of eggs to be incubated. Shipped eggs are a bit low but neverthanless, it is a risk that we all take. I've had successful hatches when the USPS are not playing football with them.

 

Would I recommend Welsummers to a beginner? I definately would!

January 20, 2012 at 8:55 am
McSpin
Reviewed by McSpin
Pros: Medium size laying very large dark eggs
Cons: Large comb prone to frostbite in cold climates

There are two general groups of Welsummes available.  Hatchery birds and those from a Breeder.  The line you obtain can vary greatly in qualities.  It is important to select the source carefully if you are after particular traits.  A good line should exhibit the following qualities:  

 

They are an efficient feeder that produces extra large to jumbo eggs from a medium sized hen.  They forage well, are disease resistant and don't require any special care.  Even with the large combs, they do very well in both hot and cold climates.  The housing simply has to be proper. 

 

The beautiful dark, speckled extra large eggs are very desirable.  A good hen should lay approximately 180-200 eggs/year.  It's not a production breed, but it holds it's own.  The vast majority of hens will not go broody.  For me, this is a very positive quality.  I hate it when hens quit laying for a couple months when I want eggs.  

 

The roosters are not generally aggressive.  Out of the 50+ roosters I've owned, only one could be considered aggressive and even that was towards only one particular person.  Overall temperament is about middle-of-the-road in the chicken world.  They are not what I would call friendly, but are also not flighty.  In general you can get them to come right up to you, but they will not want you to handle them.

 

They are not dual-purpose, but how many breeds actually grow fast enough to truly be considered dual-purpose?  In my opinion - none.   It's more like - I want a good layer that is at least large enough to eat when the need arises.  The 5-6 month old cockerels are very edible. 

 

They are my favorite breed primarily because of the egg quality, size and color. 

ChrisRenee
Reviewed by ChrisRenee
Pros: Super Dark Chocolate Eggs, Great coloring, None Aggressive, Free Range Well.,
Cons: Combs will freeze in winter, if extremely cold.

Purchased my Welsummers from Classy Poultry. They have a flock of "Pure Original Lowell Barber Welsummers" no added bloodline. These birds came straight from Lowell, before he died. These are the darkest laying welsummers, I have ever owned. Their eggs are about as dark as my Black Copper Marans. You can not put them in the same egg basket, it's hard to tell them apart. Would recommend their stock to anyone that wants great birds.

January 21, 2012 at 12:14 pm
tracyjenner
Reviewed by tracyjenner

Great birds docile, productive and good in a wide variety of temperatures.

January 23, 2012 at 10:08 pm
speralta
Reviewed by speralta
Pros: Attractive eggs, fits in well w/flock
Cons: flighty, so-so layer, too small for dual purpose

A beautiful bird that produces very attractive speckled terra cotta eggs,  Ours have fit in well with other birds in our flock, being neither dominant nor timid.

January 11, 2012 at 7:38 am
mandelyn
Reviewed by mandelyn
Pros: Good layer of dark speckled eggs, calm, great forager though handles confinement well,
Cons: none!

I LOVE this breed! You don't have to buy them friendly to get them friendly. They start laying right on schedule at 24-26 weeks of age. Their coloring helps protect them during free range but they also seem to do well in confinement.

 

Nice all around bird.

February 26, 2012 at 3:15 pm
island2island
Reviewed by island2island
Pros: egg color

Had a welsummer hen in Texas that had the most beautiful eggs so got a trio up here in NY.  This is the first time I have had a rooster (have 8 hens) and he is a welsummer and is pretty mean.  He has gotten smart enough to only attack when our backs are turned.  The girls are docile.  Took a lot longer to start laying compared with 2 other breeds gotten at the same time and they do produce fewer eggs.  Got them from a lady with a hobby farm so maybe the rooster acting up is atypical for the breed?  He's a nice looker but kind of scary.  We have to kick him a lot.

February 27, 2012 at 11:25 am
raquel3271
Reviewed by raquel3271
Pros: good layers
Cons: tend to be broody

had 3 hens of this breed and didn't know it until i found this sight! we had just called them game hens up till now but anyway.... beautiful breed and good layers as well as hardy. one of our hens brooded around 2 times in a year so they can be like that and moderate agression towards the others.

Spitzhauben1
Reviewed by Spitzhauben1
Pros: Beautiful, Productive, Good, Smart, and Easy Going
Cons: Curious

What I mean by curious being a bad thing is that, think of Curious George. Sometimes his Curiousity got him into some trouble.

Looking for a well-rounded bird-Perfect

March 5, 2012 at 11:12 am
Teresia
Reviewed by Teresia
Pros: pretty eggs
Cons: sort of wild

Lovely hen and dark brown speckled eggs. She didn't start laying until she was six months old. Laid steadily for a month, then quit for two months before starting to lay steadily again. She is standoffish with humans and the other hens. She likes to fly the coop and prefers to sleep outside rather than in the hen house, especially in the cherry tree.

March 7, 2012 at 8:07 pm
sonomachicks
Reviewed by sonomachicks
Pros: lay big eggs
Cons: infrequent

My Welsummer lays huge eggs, however, she takes a lot breaks in between. Every two, three eggs she lays, she will rest for day or two.

KKatknap
Reviewed by KKatknap
Pros: Huge, beautiful eggs; long laying season; hardy; friendly, but not cuddly
Cons: Seem to prefer to free range (not a con for me, but might be for some)...which does mean searching for eggs upon occasion.

Bought my Wellsummers from Lenster here on BYC...I will definitely be getting more at some point. They have been such a joy, and their eggs are literally remarkable. People always comment on their size and color when they buy eggs.

The hens are very friendly, although they don't love being picked up. They do love being "in your business" when you are out doing things. Mine decided early on that coop life wasn't for them, and they pop out and free range every day. They are pretty aware, though, as I live where there are all kinds of land and air predators and haven't ever lost any.

One of my 4 did go broody, and was an excellent mother. She was the most ferocious guardian of her chicks of all my broodies.

March 15, 2012 at 3:24 pm
m.r.heavenlyhens
Reviewed by m.r.heavenlyhens
Pros: Beautiful large eggs
Cons: Love their freedom

  I own several different breeds and these have become my favorite.   I must be lucky because my hens are rather calm and not at all flighty. They do love to be around me, but they are rather aloof. They LOVE to be out and forage.  In the evening when the other breed hens are hanging out at the feeder, they are still out in the field.  I have a couple of young roosters and they are perfect gentlemen.  They are very non violent and are great for predator watch.  Much nicer than my other roosters!

March 23, 2012 at 1:19 pm
RedDrgn
Reviewed by RedDrgn
Pros: good layer hardy beautiful bird/eggs intelligent friendly
Cons: slow to mature somewhat aloof

Beautiful bird and beautiful eggs; not as early to mature or as prolific and consistent a layer as some, but still good.  Friendly, but prefers to be left to do their own thing.  Always puzzling out how to get into something they shouldn't!

April 6, 2012 at 5:37 pm
Puppis
Reviewed by Puppis
Pros: Gorgeous, Non aggressive, good forager, inquisitve, good watchdog
Cons: seemed to be easily bullied

I bought some Welsummer hatching eggs but only one hatched (I was too impatient three years ago and kept candling the eggs) and of course it was a rooster. 

 

That summer I hatched many roosters and most were purebreds (large variety)  and I hated to give them up but slowly did.  I kept the Welsummer because he was always bullied and had to stay away from the main flock all day long.  Once he was the head rooster he "came into his own" got on very well with everyone.  

 

He was a good "watch dog", alerting the hens to danger when ever necessary.  He managed to live here three years and no predators got him - my second oldest chicken to date.  We lose many chickens every year.  

 

He is good with hens, not a pain in butt jumping on them all day long.  He helps them forage well.  

 

I just gave him away three weeks ago to a family with children and hens because I had too many of his offspring and I need to hatch eggs every year to replenish my flock.  But I have some lovely mixed hens that are his offspring that lay very nice dark speckled eggs.  I miss seeing him but he has a safer home now.  smile.png

January 15, 2012 at 7:43 pm
larsonll
Reviewed by larsonll
Pros: Friendly and smart
Cons: We haven't found any

Our Lilla was bought from a local farm at a few days old and is part of a mixed group of a Wheaton Maran, 2 EEs, and a game hen, a Pumpkin Hulsey.  The Welsummer is our lap chicken.  She chases my daughter around the yard and is our friendliest chicken.  I don't have a lot of experience with other breeds, but she is our favorite.  If she is a representative of the breed, we want more.

January 11, 2012 at 12:30 pm
galadtomeetya
Reviewed by galadtomeetya
Pros: beautiful dark sometimes speckled eggs, nice-looking roos!
Cons: non-setting (although for some, this may be a pro!)

I LOVE my Wellies! My roo is pretty & well-behaved; my hens lay well & have beautiful eggs. Couldn't ask for more!

 

 

.

April 4, 2012 at 4:23 pm
metzbower
Reviewed by metzbower

.

January 11, 2012 at 6:14 pm
Lbrad7
Reviewed by Lbrad7
Pros: BEAUTIFUL!!! Very gentle, beautiful painted eggs.
Cons: Can be a hard breed to find..

This breed is in the top 5 of my favorite breeds ever. Both the hens and roos are incredibly beautiful. They have very gentle personalities to humans and other birds but in my experience they are right at the top of the pecking order. The eggs are a beautiful teracotta color that customers love!

 

If you can find a breeder, I would put them on my must have list!

BackYard Chickens › Breeds & Supplies › Chicken Breeds › Welsummer › Welsummer Reviews