EFowl and Hoovers Hatchery
Featured Stories on BackYard Chickens
That stinks. I think I've seen eFowl getting some bad reviews on third party sites, and it's always best to skip the middleman. I have always ordered from Ideal Poultry in Texas (it's the hatchery closest to me!) and have been pleased with the quality and pricing of their birds. Customer service is pretty good too. I once had a chick arrive dead, they refunded me no questions asked. Only problem I have with them is on all pullet orders, there seem to be quite a few cockerels. Oh well, no hatchery is perfect, and the males don't go to waste...
Hope you have good luck with your "mystery" birds. :)