I found a MUCH better camera spot, but still haven't caught my thief. I'm getting eggs again, though, so that's exciting.
So I never saw him coming in (either he came in the other side, or a duck was in the way of the camera when he came in this way) but here's Fat Ben leaving in disappointment
One of my ducks looking ready to charge!
Here's Ben coming back in (never saw him leave)
At some point between 5:30 and this picture, an egg was laid! There were a bunch of ducks blocking that part of the shot during that time, though.
At some point, the egg gets kicked over a bit
Then another one appears out of nowhere! No shots of anyone laying here, so I'm assuming it was laid somewhere offscreen and then kicked over here later.
The egg in the back gets knocked over again
I'm not sure what got all of their attention, but I like the profile shots...
And this one I kept because it shows Mirage's pretty face stripes and a little bit of her mottling