So I went through and was re-reading everyone's comments about our possible cockerel and I think I discovered something. Everyone kept saying the lighter color possibly indicates chicken nugget #2 is a male; however, I don't think the picture of chicken nugget #1 does it justice. I believe the picture makes the first one appear darker than the second but in actuality they are almost identical in every way. The only differences we can see are the orangeish face and legs vs a darker face and legs. But if they are not showing off much of a comb at 10 weeks, I'm starting to think all our "ladies" are in fact all ladies... What do you think?
I think they're both pullets. There are individual differences, some slightly lighter, some darker, but most every BR male would have a very distinct comb by 10 weeks old.