Originally Posted by MrsKuhn
These two are the one in question. They were in the bin labeled Ameraucanas. The bright red combs are what are making me think Roo but from researching I have found a lot of pictures that make it look like that is normal for this breed. I see no waddles forming.
Top one is Mary Poopins AKA Big Bird
Bottom one is Shelia ( my son named it )
That is quite a lot of comb for 6 weeks. In the group photos it *looks like* they've got green legs which I believe makes them Easter Eggers, but that's one of those things retailers do. My understanding is that a lot of the white and black patterns do tend to be male- also EE's don't usually get wattles- just combs. I'll toss my guess in as both are cockerels- haven't had any EE cockerels myself but I have a couple pullets that didn't pink up until quite a bit later.
Great job with the photos!