Help!!! I got these 2 chicks about a month ago. I'm pretty sure the EE is a roo. I need help with the Polish though. I'm really hoping shes a girl but i'm really not sure. Please help! Thanks, here are some photos.
I'm 95% that your polish is a pullet, they can be hard to sex though often keeping you guessing for quite some time. No wattles, tidy crest and a pullet looking tail makes me think female for the polish.
I would also say you are right on the other, looks very cockerel like to me.