Ok... I know where you are. You have to forgive me... I'm new to Ohio, now I see it was a silly question! LOL I live a bit north and east of the village up the hill passed the mansion. I'd be happy to introduce you to my girls if you want to meet the flock.
I ordered from Meyer in September and my chicks came in late October. It was a great transaction and I am very happy with my girls. I don't know of anything local except for someone who posts on Craigslist up in Johnstown listing http://columbus.craigslist.org/grd/3540422538.html I've also heard that Tractor Supply has chicks in the Spring as does Granville Milling but I don't know about that for sure.
I've heard not to order from the Johnstown Chicken Peddler. Birds live in awful conditions from what I hear. There are too many good breeders to waste time with peddlers.