Quote:
Originally Posted by
Indiana Ima 
And now I have just been told (in a Bloomington specific chicken group on facebook) that "Wyandottes can sometimes be a bit on the aggressive side." Do y'all agree?
If you're just getting hens, not roosters, then no I do not agree. Even hatchery wyandottes, which *can* be a little more aggressive towards other birds are most likely to be docile towards people. I do agree, from my limited experience with my one hatchery silver laced wyandotte (SLW) that they can be more aggressive towards other birds in the flock than the other breeds you've listed. Mine is sweet as pie to us, always has been, but last summer when we were having feather picking problems she was the only one that wasn't missing any feathers.
Quote:
Beautiful birds! I am a complete newbie here, trying to decide whether to buy 5 (the maximum allowed in my town) Black Australorps, 5 Silver Laced Wyandottes, or maybe 5 Ameracaunas. I want beautiful hens with a high egg laying capability, acceptable as an eating/meat bird when they are done laying, social and friendly and easy to keep.
In the reading I've done I keep seeing that Silver Laced Wyandottes are really good cold weather chickens. That their combs don't freeze and that they lay even in cold weather. It gets below freezing every night for at least a few months here in Bloomington, Indiana, so that sounds good to me!
Are there other reasons you think I should go with Silver Laced Wyandottes as my final choice? This looks like the right place to discuss the qualities and negatives of that breed!
I guess the question is where you are looking to get birds from? Hatchery wyandottes and wyandottes from dedicated hobby breeders are like two totally different breeds. Wyandottes from a breeder are going to be larger, more likely to have correct comb type and good lacing, and from all accounts I've heard they tend to be a bit more docile in temperament. If you're getting your birds from a hatchery (or through a feedstore, since 95% of the time feed stores get their birds from hatcheries) then I'd say any of the breeds you're looking at are going to be pretty similar in egg production, meat production, and temperament. Hatchery wyandottes (at least mine) really don't have any more meat on them than easter eggers (what many hatcheries sell as "Ameraucanas.")