How come people are so anxious to help chicks hatch?

post #1 of 47

4/12/08 at 2:59pm

Thread Starter

hinkjc

Location: PA
Joined: 1/2007
Posts: 12,685
offline

Select All Posts By This User

The point of my question is in reference to all of the folks who post "my egg pipped, when should I help". I am a bit concerned that folks are getting the impression this is the norm, when helping chicks hatch should always be a last resort.

If all of your incubation controls were proper, it should not be necessary to help..ever. If you know you had challenges, it is best to wait until the hatch is finished before even opening an incubator, since the hatching environment should always be kept consistent. Even opening it only slightly to take a peak impacts the hatch and disturbs the environment. These types of disturbances cannot be recovered from, regardless of how "fast you got the humidity back up".

Let's consider it from a different perspective. A mama hen never leaves her nest until she feels the hatch is complete and babies are ready for the world. She generally does not assist weak or defective young and let's nature make the decision as to their fate. I'm not saying that's what we should do, in all cases..but in most I feel we should make every attempt to withhold our urge to interfere and let the hatch take its natural course.

I hope folks will find this as an educational post for anyone new to hatching. It is not meant to say helping is right or wrong, but I think people are helping too much or too soon, which can cause more harm than good for their hatches.

Good luck to all who are hatching and I wish you lots of happy healthy chicks! jumpy

Jody

Breeds: Lavender, Buff, Black and White Orpington & Tufted Rumpless Araucana (lavender, white and nonstandard colors)

post #2 of 47

4/12/08 at 3:25pm

Katy
Flock Mistress

Location: Kansas~50+ yrs of chickens
Joined: 6/2007
Posts: 16,319
offline

Select All Posts By This User

I agree with Jody 100%!!

I'm a Farmer/Rancher Wife,Mom & Grandma No Farms, No food.
If you want house chickens and ducks in diapers then this is the forum for you.
I've got 50+ years of poultry experience, but this 'poultry' forum isn't for me anymore.
If you're going to complain about farmers, don't do it with a full belly or a mouthful.

post #3 of 47

4/12/08 at 3:45pm

CUDA

Location: Michigan
Joined: 3/2008
Posts: 1,250
offline

Select All Posts By This User

This sounds similar to a thread I started hinkjc...lol! Yep I agree with you all the way!

It is a thousand times better to have common sense without education, than to have education without common sense. Robert Ingersoll
Stevens Poultry Farm
My Fathers Mission Work

post #4 of 47

4/12/08 at 3:45pm

theOEGBman

Location: Central California
Joined: 1/2007
Posts: 3,060
offline

Select All Posts By This User

I also agree with you, Jody. If a chick doesnt have the strength to break out of an egg, how healthy will it really be?

God loves you whether you like it or not! & I support the Poultry Industry!

post #5 of 47

4/12/08 at 3:48pm

speckledhen
Intentional Solitude

Location: N. Georgia Mtns.
Joined: 2/2007
Posts: 63,966
offline

Select All Posts By This User

Now, if you could just convince my DH of that. I agree and I'm going to try to hold him back this time. I've told people how to help if they decide to do so, but honestly, that is a tough decision for me. I don't think it should be the norm at all.

~A dog on its owner's property is a pet; A dog on someone else's property is a predator~

Truth Above Tradition

Speckledhen's Ten Commandments of Good Flock Management

Living the Good Life in the North Georgia Mountains~ Cynthia

~A dog on its owner's property is a pet; A dog on someone else's property is a predator~

Truth Above Tradition

Speckledhen's Ten Commandments of Good Flock Management

Living the Good Life in the North Georgia Mountains~ Cynthia

post #6 of 47

4/12/08 at 3:50pm

RoostersCrow

Location: Out of the government's sight
Joined: 4/2008
Posts: 295
offline

Select All Posts By This User

"Helping" a chick out can very often lead to hemorage and death. Generally best to leave nature alone.

I'm no spring chicken but I'm still having fun!

George

post #7 of 47

4/12/08 at 3:59pm

Tuffoldhen
Flock Mistress

Location: WV
Joined: 1/2007
Posts: 7,500
offline

Select All Posts By This User

Jody, You hit the nail on the head...I have NEVER had to help a chick out when its hatching and I have hatched out hundreds of chicks..... People are impatient and don't listen when you say Do not open the incubator, they don't watch their temps or humidity during a hatch or try tweaking it on day 18 or beyond and that never works out well... smile

Smith/Giles "project" Lavender Orpingtons, Spring of 2012 Part English "project" Lavenders , Part English BBS Orpingtons, Buff Orpingtons and Bantam Light Brahmas. Follow me down the yellow brick road!!!

I'm holding out for the gold star !!!!

post #8 of 47

4/12/08 at 4:13pm

ebonykawai

Location: Wheatfield, NY near NiagFalls
Joined: 12/2007
Posts: 1,307
offline

Select All Posts By This User

I agree, too. I know that for me, I had to develop a thick skin and had to keep telling myself "Even mamma hens don't get 100% hatches or perfect babies every time. Mamma hens cull, too, via nature." I had 4 eggs this past hatch and it was day 23 with no pips. That was my cutoff point. In the real world, mamma hen would have probably abandoned the eggs, as well, and started taking care of the 11 babies already there. I'll never help in a hatch. It's just not natural.

This topic should be stickied underneath the 'helping to hatch' thread so people can make better, more fuller decisions.

Edited by ebonykawai - 4/12/08 at 4:16pm

Lisa
1 hubby, 2 kids (ok, 1 is 18 now, so not technically a kid), 3 dogs, 1 cat, 1 hamster, and a 10 beautiful RIRs!

post #9 of 47

4/12/08 at 5:30pm