"Scrambled" in Macedon, NY

Since you are getting a variety of answers, you need to research the city code and zoning yourself; obviously not everyone downtown is on the ball or even the same page.

First, figure out what your zoning is, and then look up allowed uses.  Next, look up anything on animals and pets.  With a handful of hens, you can make a fairly strong case that they are pets.  With a 1000 bird layer-barn you cannot.  The coop may or may not require a building permit--depends on your city, and the type of coop you plan. 

In my city, structures that are over 200 sq ft or over 8' tall require a building permit.  Smaller and it does not unless it will be wired for electric or plumbed for water.  But I have seen code that required a permit for a small doghouse! (ridiculous IMO).

Each time you speak with a town official, make sure to get their name and title.  Saying "Elvira Smith in the planning and zoning office said "blah, blah, blah..."  Or "Fred Brown the city clerk told me "duh, duh, duh..." carries more weight than "someone at city hall told me I could have 4 hens."  Be sure to ask for the city code or zoning reference that allows hens.

Well, it is hard to say if "Judy" or the other person is the one who does not know.  THat's why its useful to ask for references in the code itself.

Tiffany,
    I'm sorry that you're having problems with the town.  Let me know what zoning you're in.  You can find this possibly in your taxes, but you definitely can find it on the towns map.  I'll send you a PM so you I can help you further.  Remember that the code is what matters, never what a town employee says.

Hi I am up the road in Palmyra. Just wondering how this turned out.