If the pics/angles are reliable, this one seems to have a longer back and better tail angle, but the other one has better barring throughout the tail. You might try spreading their wings out and look for strong barring there. From an SOP standpoint, the combs would be the last consideration after body type, color and pattern.
Thank you so much! I have always followed the posts when others ask about their birds, but it's been really interesting to have this group of boys and evaluate them, and then the input means so much more. I've been sitting and watching them.
I'm still actually struggling with the decision of whether to keep any of them, as I'm pretty full up on chickens. This helps think about it.
- Ant Farm