BackYard Chickens › BYC Forum › Other BackYard Poultry › Geese › Embdems or pilgrim geese which is best?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Embdems or pilgrim geese which is best?

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 

I have some tufted buff geese , Love them, but am going to get a few more different breed of geese, and am trying to figure out which type,

anyone raise both types? which do you prefer and why?

 

 

  is pilgrim geese hard to get to reproduce ? and emdems  a lot easier?      I do have kids who love the tufted buff, also thought about the tufted romans but afraid they might fly off.. the hatchery I want to get the geese from only allows you to buy pairs or your allowed a trio of emdems .

post #2 of 8

I have regular American Buff -- my kids love them.  I almost got Pilgrims though because they have similar personalities.  Now, I kind of wish I had gotten Pilgrims in the beginning as then I could tell for sure who was male and who was female.   But, we love the Buffs so they are staying.  If I ever get more geese I will be getting Pilgrims since we love the Buff personality and then I'll know what sexes I have . . .

EE, Buff Orp, Jersey Giant, White Silkie, Barred Rock, Dominique, Cuckoo Maran, Welsummer and Cochin chickens,  9 Welsh Harlequin ducks, 2 Rouen ducks,  9 American Buff geese, one patient husband, 4 children of assorted ages from 5 - 15
Reply
EE, Buff Orp, Jersey Giant, White Silkie, Barred Rock, Dominique, Cuckoo Maran, Welsummer and Cochin chickens,  9 Welsh Harlequin ducks, 2 Rouen ducks,  9 American Buff geese, one patient husband, 4 children of assorted ages from 5 - 15
Reply
post #3 of 8

 

I have Pilgrims and I love this breed. I don't have another breed to compare to but before getting my geese I heard all sorts of horror stories about how mean geese are. Totally not true of Pilgrims, they absolutely LOVE my goat and don't give any of my poultry any trouble. I really like that I will be able to tell my goslings apart at hatch. No need to sex vent, I will be able to sell goslings and not have to worry about giving the wrong sex.

 

Are you a located in WV, PA or MD? Join our homesteaders group today!

                        https://www.facebook.com/groups/109802325876029/?notif_t=group_r2j

 

Reply

Are you a located in WV, PA or MD? Join our homesteaders group today!

                        https://www.facebook.com/groups/109802325876029/?notif_t=group_r2j

 

Reply
post #4 of 8

Hi,

I have troulouse and chinese grey and my females are very gentle.  My gander is a chinese and he is aggressive but after catching him a few times he has learned to stay his distance.  I love the troulouse as they are very gentle.  I just clip one of my gander's wings and all of my females stay in with him even though they can fly.  I have also tried to get my geese to roam outside of my fenced area and they won't leave the yard.  I am guessing it is because they are leary of unexplored areas.  Clipping one wing doesn't hurt them at all ond you only have to take a few inches off of the very end of the feathers to unbalance them enough to get them to stay in.  Good luck.

Littledear

Reply

Littledear

Reply
post #5 of 8

I would have to go for true Embdens and they're such impressive birds.  I should stop myself but would love to get a pair this year and have the opportunity to get a pair from an excellent bloodline.

HELLO FROM ENGLAND
Keeping; Exhibition Dewlap Toulouse (Grey & Buff), Buff Africans, Sebastopols, Rheas & Parrots.

 

NEW PICTURE ALBUMS ADDED.
 

Reply

HELLO FROM ENGLAND
Keeping; Exhibition Dewlap Toulouse (Grey & Buff), Buff Africans, Sebastopols, Rheas & Parrots.

 

NEW PICTURE ALBUMS ADDED.
 

Reply
post #6 of 8
Thread Starter 

I think metzer farms are supposed to have some above average  embdens  , Its just so hard to choose

 

 Is pilgrim geese hard to get to reproduce and embdens easier I wonder?

post #7 of 8

If you decide to get embdens get them from Holderreads.   My parents had some hatchery embdens, and they weren't particularly nice, but I have some Embdens from Holderreads and some I raised from the original pair last year, and they are much, much larger and much more even tempered.  I've had no problems with them so far.

 

post #8 of 8

I have an Embden x Pilgrim, and at only 5 months old, she is a character. She is boss of all the animals on our property. Very great goose.

Mumma to 11 Muscovies, 4 Pekins, 5 Indian Runners, 3 Call Ducks, 4 Mixed Breeds, 1 Silkie, 1 Magpie Goose and 1 Embden x Pilgrim. Also a Beagledore, a Wolfhound, a bunny, a guinea pig, many cats and a Boyfriend.

Reply

Mumma to 11 Muscovies, 4 Pekins, 5 Indian Runners, 3 Call Ducks, 4 Mixed Breeds, 1 Silkie, 1 Magpie Goose and 1 Embden x Pilgrim. Also a Beagledore, a Wolfhound, a bunny, a guinea pig, many cats and a Boyfriend.

Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Geese
BackYard Chickens › BYC Forum › Other BackYard Poultry › Geese › Embdems or pilgrim geese which is best?