I'm in NH, and my parents had ordered from MM a couple of times when I was a kid. We always enjoyed trying to identify the mystery chick. My parents never had any problems with their chicks.
I got my first order 11Jun12, and my daughter has enjoyed them so much. I ordered 25 chicks ( a variety of breeds) and got the free mystery chick. They sent me 30 chicks! I had one DOA, and then lost 3 more-but I still ended up with 26 so I was happy with that. Our mystery chick is a Japanese Bantam. I would order from them again.