To help? Or not to help? Pls share your experiences.

Im with you. Im on day 19 right now and i was worried about if any of them needed help.

My wife has had to help all our duck and geese eggs hatch so far, this is our first time hatching geese and duck eggs. All are doing fine, and some are still hatching. They are walking around eating and drinking. Never had much luck with helping the chicken eggs though.

I will intervene only if they have been pipped for close to 36 hrs. I just finished my hatch  on Friday and the only chick I helped was pipped for over 30 hrs and zero progress on the zip, he was also 2 days late. Then I will only open the area at the air cell and see if they are shrink wrapped. If they are shrink wrapped I free up the parts that are stuck and wet down the rest and back in the 'bator they go. The one I helped on Friday had pipped and partially zipped. You could clearly see where he was shrink wrapped. I ended taking him completely out of the shell. BTW if a chick has heavy bleeding on their bum a quick fix is flour! Put some in a bowl and dip their whole bum in it. ( I was out of the antibiotic powder)

We completely help if they've pipped but made no progress after 12 hours. We assess what the problem is (we've had experience with the following issues while hatching):

1) Shrink wrapped. Was our first hatch and the hydrometer was off by 20%! We opened enough of the egg and slammed up the humidity so that it was able to get itself out the rest of the way. The chick is now a healthy strapping rooster.

2) The chick was a stargazer. It had a Thiamine ( Vitamin B1) deficiency due the breeder's birds lack of proper supplementation. She wasn't strong enough to fully unzip so we helped her enough that she could get out the rest of the way. We gave the chick proper support nutritionally and by her 2nd day, she was perfectly healthy and is now a huge lovely Lavender Orp layer.

3) The chick was enormous! Too big for the egg. He wasn't able to get past pipping (over 12 hours), he didn't have enough room in the egg to maneuver into position to unzip. We ended up removing a full half of the shell and rolling him out of the egg. He's now a HUGE Lav Orp rooster named "Hot Fuzz"...he was the fluffiest of all the chicks.

Sometimes it's our error that prevents a chick from hatching. When we help, we do just enough so that we can see their beak and that they are able to breathe. After that, we try and let them do it themselves because if they can, we know they are normal, healthy and strong, they just needed a little hand. It's a value judgement to help or not.

We look at it this way -- if we were in the same situation, we'd want someone to give us every chance possible. And if the chick truly isn't healthy, it will die after it hatches anyway so what's wrong with making sure a healthy chick didn't die in the egg because of some odd ball situation like human error.

I said before that I wouldn't help hatch- natural selection and all that.  Then I actually started to hatch chicks.

I have now helped two chicks out. The first time, it had been pipped over 24 hours and had partially zipped, but was trying to push out without zipping as much as they should. I zipped a little bit more, and she popped right out. Unfortunately, she had spraddle leg. I'm not sure if it was a defect before and that's why she couldn't properly hatch herself out, or if it was an injury due to the prolonged hatching time. Regardless, her condition got worse, and I ended up having to cull her two weeks later. I  regretted helping her, because I got extremely attached to her and took her death very hard.

The second chick I helped had been pipped for 36 hours or so, and had made no progress. He had pipped through a vessel and I wondered if the blood loss hurt his strength. He seemed to be getting weaker and weaker. So, I finally peeled him out of the egg. He was exhausted at first, and seemed a little smaller, but within a few days, he was perfect. He is now almost two months old, and a beautiful little cockerel.

I've never helped. I'm on probably my last day of incubation. I had 23/36 eggs hatch, and there's one in there that hasn't shown any progress. Just pipped through the membrane and shell. I took it out because I thought it was dead, but then it peeped at me, to right back in it went. If it doesn't show any progress within the next couple of hours and is still alive, I will probably help it zip, just to see what happens. The remaining eggs are showing nothing. No pips, no peeps. I'll leave the incubator going till tomorrow - that will be Day 24. But I don't know that I would help any of them if they get started and can't get out themselves.