So.... average...

 You keep trying. All this means is you have not found your passion yet. When you do, you will not be average.
 

I'll tell you what you're good at...writing. That was my passion for a season. I wrote all of the time, not for anyone else, just for me. I was brilliant (didn't matter what anyone else thought , I was writing for me). Then my passion changed, to animals, a few years later, gardening. I loved my animals like no one else would, and my gardens are still beautiful. I did start singing, always had, but oneday someone heard me, now I'm on the praise-n-worship at church.

If you really want to know your talents just think of what you love and go from there. Do it for you, and no one else. We are all talented, just maybe not discovered. The best thing you could ever do for yourself is to ask God to help you find these things out, He knows you better than you know yourself, He will answer.
 

The people who are brilliant at what they do aren't always the ones who are successful. The world is full of "also rans" who made good, simply because they ran harder or longer than the ones who seemed more talented at the start. Did you know that Michael Jordan didn't make the basketball team the first time he tried out for it?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_jordan

Or take Charles Shultz. His Peanuts cartoon strip was the most widely syndicated cartoon of its time, and has given us such iconic characters as Charlie Brown and Snoopy. Did you know that his drawings were rejected by his high school yearbook? 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_M._Schulz

Not everyone discovers their "true calling" early in life. And, not everyone can be #1, But success isn't measured by how many people you "beat." I saw an interview with Jack Warden once. He was a very good actor, nominated several times for big awards, but only won one - an Emmy for his supporting role in Brian's Song, a film I'll bet you've never heard of. In the interview, Warden said,"I'm a character actor, not a leading man. The leading men get the big money, and the fame, but a few years from now, nobody wants to hire them. A character actor will always find work."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Warden

So you don't feel like a superstar. That's ok. Sometimes, the true MVP's can be the steady sloggers, the ones you can count on for a solid performance.

 Excuse me, your drawings are AMAZING. Seriously. If they were on a t-shirt, I would so totally want one.

 I also consider you to be one of the funniest people on this entire website. Actually, Justbugged and I were planting raspberries whilst goofing off and talking about all the BYCers, and you came up. We both consider you to be a riot, and great fun to have around. And as far as feeling smart... Come on! I feel average every time I talk to you! So you're doing fine.

 Give yourself time. I didn't even start to grow into my self until I was in my thirties. If I am lucky I will see some of my passions bear some fruit before I am fifty. Maybe

The key is to just keep going and to not get down. Just keep trying. Keep learning. Keep expanding. I bet others don't see you as being average.
 

Honestly, I think you are amazing for being able to enjoy Chemistry; I'm pretty jealous.  I am an Environmental Biology major and I have to take several Chemistry courses.  I can't get into them at all, so I'm not doing well.  Also, I think if you are passionate about something, it is exciting no matter what it is.  It doesn't have to be another person's idea of an exciting activity like art or music, if you love it, go all in!  Try not to judge yourself by others, you are awesome because you are you!
I