
Can't really say, but I have an observation from my own flock: my roosters are not aggressive. There's no flipping from friendly to aggressive with them. As a matter of fact, roosters will break up hen squabbles. My dominant rooster is watchful when I'm around the flock, and he caters to me. He almost flogged me ONCE when he and a hen got out of the fenced area, wanted back in but forgot how they got out, and I rescued them. I picked up the hen first. She squawked and he flapped at me while I boosted her over the fence. Then I hoisted him up and over.
Anybody can walk through my flock and not encounter even one aggressive rooster in the five of 'em. They'd be watchful and alert, but they'd keep their distance.
So I don't understand the reference about "the hen side of her coming out when she is not being aggressive."
There's always been a "bossy" hen or two in my flock. They peck very junior hens out of their way just because they out-rank 'em..
That's just it. I've never seen her be bossy to any of the other hens, and I'm with them alot. Not even the poor little Silkies that everyone else picks on. What's funny is for the first time in a long time, she didn't go after me last night. She must know I've been talking about her, lol! I've had sweet roos, and I've had a nasty roo. Like you, there was no going back and forth in behavior. The sweet one was very respectful of me, even attacked one of his hens when she went after me! (she was broody at the time, and mean). Our roo that was naughty, you wouldn't dare turn your back on him. I'm not so worried with Manly,since she is no where near that aggressive. But I do miss the feeling of being able to walk freely through the chicken yard, especially if I am wearing shorts or sandals, without looking behind me. And she follows me EVERYWHERE!!
Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance.
-Confucius
Real knowledge is to know the extent of one's ignorance.
-Confucius






