I agree, he could make a fine meal, cooked appropriately. But I also see you point on not being able to eat him yourself, that's just a call for you to make. If nothing else, maybe save the broth you get from cooking it for the dogs and freeze it for a month or so. When you pull it out to use it, there will be that needed distance from the live animal, makes it much easier to eat at that point. We have a saying here.......MRTB*
*Mean Roosters Taste Better
*Mean Roosters Taste Better