I went with both hatcheries this year. I ordered ducks and geese from McMurray and a bunch of chicks. So far, we have been going well with both. I lost a duckling a couple days after I got them. She had some kind of growth on her neck. We first thought she was just eating a lot, but it never got better and she never grew. All others are doing well though.
Meyer chicks did okay. We lost a couple of Buttercups, and we're not sure what happened. The hatchery was understanding and offered replacements so long as the order consisted of three chicks. I had to buy a third, but hey, free shipping. Chicken math win. :D