I went ahead and exchanged it. Do you think it was a rooster? I wasn't sure at all, but it already had a comb growing on its head that made me a bit suspicious.
So the chick with the yellow spot on its head has a weird foot. I'm doing the whole band aid toe thing, but it doesn't really seem like it is a toe issue as much as an ankle issue. The ankle isn't bending like normal so it's foot won't flatten. It is almost walking on its tip toes. It still runs...