Barred Plymouth Rock- six week old Cockerel?

[vyyouvyanybody]

I have a dilemma! I know I for sure have one cockerel, but I am unsure if I have two. “Philip” is my obvious cockerel, and “Other Philip” is my less obvious. Other Philip is darker, but also has a reddish comb and is just now getting his wattles. I have a farmer friend who will trade me a rooster for a hen (his chicks are the same age), and I would be trading Other Philip. But he wants to know really soon! Any ideas would be helpful, see photos! (First photo: Other Philip at top of photo, Philip at the bottom) (Last photo: tail feathers from Philip, Other Philip does not have these tail feathers.) Thanks for the help!!

 

[MysteryChicken]

Both are cockerels.

 

[vyyouvyanybody]

Both are cockerels.

Is it the comb that gives it away?

 

[MysteryChicken]

Is it the comb that gives it away?

Mostly yes. Can you get a better picture of the darker ones front, the chest, & face like the first one? Just for confirmation.

 

[vyyouvyanybody]

Mostly yes. Can you get a better picture of the darker ones front, the chest, & face like the first one? Just for confirmation.

For sure, I’ll try tomorrow when there’s good light! Thanks for your help!

 

[MysteryChicken]

A pullet looks like this.
This a Heritage Plymouth Barred Rock, not hatchery stock, but you can still see the difference in female barring.

 

[MysteryChicken]

For sure, I’ll try tomorrow when there’s good light! Thanks for your help!

Okay, you're welcome.