Best Incubator?

Discussion in 'Incubating & Hatching Eggs' started by Gammond, Jun 3, 2017.

  1. Gammond

    Gammond Chillin' With My Peeps

    198
    48
    81
    Aug 31, 2016
    Central BC, Canada
    Looking at purchasing a 42ish egg incubator. Mine broke after being 20 years old. I'm looking at adding everything including the automatic egg turner.

    What one would you recommend? I want something that I don't have to fiddle with every day - I tried an older style Hova Bator and it seemed I was constantly adjusting the temperature screw. I did get a pretty good hatch rate though - 85%
     
  2. PD-Riverman

    PD-Riverman Overrun With Chickens

    5,000
    1,199
    366
    Jan 14, 2012
    Conway SC
    How Much money you want to spend?? If you want to keep the price low----I Love my 1602n with fan and turner.

    But having used a Little giant for many years---once or twice a season-- I set it and I never had to play with the thermostat.
     
  3. Egghead_Jr

    Egghead_Jr Overrun With Chickens

    6,034
    837
    336
    Oct 16, 2010
    NEK, VT
    Get the Genesis Hovabator with preset temp control. People really like it. I use the old wafer style Hovabator and have excellent results. The trick to temp is keep in mind it will need readjustment after three days of being on. The metal relaxes when warmed up and in use hence the slight temp change and need to nudge some. Once that is done it keeps temp for rest of incubation.

    Incubator warehouse has fair deals. You must already have an auto turner so you save that expense. Any of the styro table top style turners fit the others. For instance I use a Little Giant turner in my Hovabator as it was on sale at Tractor Supply.

    http://incubatorwarehouse.com/hova-bator-genesis-1588-egg-incubator.html
     
  4. Ridgerunner

    Ridgerunner True BYC Addict

    20,506
    3,898
    506
    Feb 2, 2009
    Northwest Arkansas
    With any incubator you need to calibrate the temperature. The factory settings can be off on even the best ones. So expect some fiddling while you get it adjusted. But I agree, you don't want to be constantly adjusting after you get it set.

    I'm not sure where you are located and what makes and models might be available for you. In the US it use to be your choices were pretty much Brinsea, Hovabator, or Little Giant in the size you are talking about, but lately I've been seeing a lot of other brands available. Best is kind of a nebulous term, depending on what your criteria are. Brinsea are generally considered the best but they are more pricey. Hovabator are probably next, but some of that may be that a lot of the LG reviews are on the really cheap still air models. A lot of chicks are hatched in all of them.

    The features I'd look for are a forced air fan, auto turner, and a decent window to see what is going on inside. After that, I'm a little more flexible. How easy is it to control humidity? Do you have to fill internal reservoirs or is there an external reservoir. Can you adjust the humidity with a dial to get some really fine tuning or is it by fiddling with sponges or rags in reservoirs? How do you adjust the temperature? I have an old-style Hovabator 1588 with those dip-switches. It's a royal pain to change the temperature settings but once I got it right it's held steady for several years.

    How often do you hatch? One advantage of the hard plastic type incubators is they are easier to clean than the foam ones. I only hatch 2 or 3 times a year. If I were hatching more often I'd probably upgrade to a hard plastic one just for ease of cleaning.

    I can't tell you which hold temperature the best. They don't make my model of the 1588 anymore, they changed the controls. I've had great luck with my 1588 in that regard once I got it set, but you've had a bad experience with Hovabator. I think a lot of that is luck in which specific incubator you get.

    I can't make a specific recommendation for you since I'm not sure any specific make and model will absolutely hold temperature without adjusting once you get it set, but when I have to replace this one I'll probably go with a Brinsea.
     
  5. orrpeople

    orrpeople Looking for a Silver Lining Premium Member

    2,165
    4,439
    321
    Jun 15, 2016
    State of Jefferson
    I have a newer 1588 - in fact, I have a couple :oops: They are pretty reliable, and I ran mine for about 6 months straight before giving them a break. Probably about 95% hatch rate on all my back yard and local eggs. Shipped eggs are always another story...but that's for another day. :)
     
    PD-Riverman likes this.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by