The light one Im asuming is a Black shoulder? I thought it was a male. It has the same primary wing feather as my old male did. It also "displays" its tail and struts (but I heard females so as well?) It is also the more brave one. My other one also displays but does not have that orangy brown primary wing feather color. Im assuming it is a India Blue? The BS I hatched on my own, the other I got as a young chick (both from different breeders). I am more a bantam cochin person (and horse person), so thank you so much for your help Here are some pics below. Oh, they are about 5 and 6 months old. The BS is the older one by about a month. Someone told me they were both hens. But I want to hear more, because not sure if I believe them.