I picked this egg up yesterday not long after she laid it and it didn't feel different than her other eggs, just had the weird coloring. Later that evening when I picked it up again, to put it in the frig, the shell started denting due to the softness of it.
I cracked it this morning and the insides were completely normal. It was a cool looking egg but Betty is getting some extra calcium in the form of crushed egg shells from now on.