I'm separating my Cayuga's and will end up with 3 hens and a Drake. I have 2 drakes one is a real fatty he is bigger than everyone and has very little color the other is slimmer and has beautiful colors. The slim one i like walks more upright while tubby walks low and waddles. They are both the same age about 4 to 5 months old My question is will the smaller one be okay to keep for breeding?? Hubby seems to think the large one will be a better breeder I however think he would be hard on the hens as he is a large one. Will he have pretty colors like the slim one? How about the slim one if he has pretty colors now will they get even better as he ages?? (you can tell i really like the slim one) I will go on what you duck experts tell me.