Can one hen lay 2 different colors of eggs? Last night my hen started laying again and I found 2 eggs in her pen. Now who else is in her pen was another chicken(hen that hasn't later yet) a small hen and a rooster. It couldn't have been the small hen because her eggs are very small. And the other girl hasn't started laying yet. So can one hen lay 2 different color eggs? One was white and one was a tanish color. Or is it safe to assume that my other hen started laying?? Thanks for any feed back!!!!!