Okay story.... My 18 yo DD has an iPod (3 years old) and wants the new iPod Touch (which I've bought already). She made the comment the other day that if she got the new iPod she wanted to give her friend the old one. Well I paid almost $300 for that iPod and I want if for myself, which I told her "if" she got one the old one was mine. I have already bought a few things for her friend. She is a very nice girl but I suspect her family life is hard. I don't like to "guess" at peoples circumstance, but they did not even have Thanksgiving Dinner? So I would like to buy her a MP3 player for Christmas. I found this nice one at Wal-Mart that has a camera also. Do you guys have any suggestions on a good MP3 player with at least a FM tuner for less than $50? http://www.walmart.com/ip/Ematic-4GB-MP3-Video-Player-Black/15126061 I did a search for reviews, but only Wal-Mart reviews can be found. Thanks, Melissa P.S. We (me, my sister, my aunt and my granny) got her some new clothes, a purse, ring, and socks. Let's just say she has made a big difference in the life of my daughter. My daughter has several mental/behavioral problems and this girl has really helped out by being my daughter's friend at school and home. This is the first friend that my daughter has kept for more than 2 months and I like having around my house.