I'm guessing this is why the list is so short:
I'm sure the store has those breeds because they are popular, and they tend to do well for many people. All of them are good choices.
Ameraucana (or Easter Egger): usually lays blue or green eggs (a few hens may lay brown instead). The chicks & adults come in many colors. They usually don't lay as many eggs as some of the others.
The other four breeds lay brown eggs.
The Barred Rocks are probably a little bit bigger and produce a little more meat than the others, but are still good egg layers. People who want chickens for eggs AND meat might choose them.
The Black Sexlinks are a hybrid that lays lots of eggs.
The Rhode Island Reds are a pure breed that lays lots of eggs.
These two are probably the best layers of the options. Other than color, I think they are very similar to each other.
The Buff Orpingtons don't lay quite as many eggs, are more likely to go broody and try to hatch eggs, and have a reputation as friendly birds. When someone has multiple breeds in a flock, I think it's common for Buff Orpingtons to be the favorite. (Of course that's not always the case, because different people have different preferences.)
Personally, I think the Buff Orpingtons look prettier than the other breeds you listed, so I'd include at least one of them in your flock
Last edited:
