Picture heavy; updated photos, please take a look..

[Momagain1]

I am trying to make sure our "guesses" are still correct:

Silkie -- was guessed to be a Roo...wdyt ..still? ALL these are Approx. 3ish months old..





Golden Laced Polish "Polinda" was said to be a "roo".... (terrible photo; but the crest feathers are slightly rounded ...but some are kinda pointy too..the comb has NOT grown any...




I think this EE'er "pullet" is really a roo...wdyt?




TIA!

 

[debilorrah]

That polish is a hen. Your silkie will not even crow til it's 8-9 months old, so you need to move the poof and if there is even a remote bit of comb it's a roo. The last photo is a roo. Look at the tail feathers and compare that to your polish - you can see hers are much higher lifted and not drooping at all the way roos tails do.

 

[BlueCamas]

They honestly all look like cockerels to me, I'm no expert though so hopefully others will chime in.

 

[ramirezframing]

the color on the polish says hen along with the shape of the crest the ee is a roo

 

[Momagain1]

what about the pointy (sorta) crest feathers...???