Pilgrim or Buff?

beccaWA

Songster
9 Years
Feb 22, 2012
329
193
211
Eastern WA
I've never raised geese, (just ducks/chickens/turkeys) but would like get some for a pasture/orchard situation. I live on one acre, and plan on putting in some fruit trees and overseeding the sparse pasture in the back. I want a more docile goose, thus the choice between the Buff and Pilgrim. I've heard Pilgrim CAN be aggressive, but they lay better than Buffs. I think both are about equal in weeding?

Recommendations from you goose owners?

Thanks!
 

oldhenlikesdogs

Dreaming of Spring
BYC Staff
Premium Feather Member
6 Years
Jul 16, 2015
47,191
86,301
1,522
Wisconsin
I vote buff as well. My pilgrims are more aggressive toward other birds, and my dogs. I personally wouldn't get them again.
 

Sierra G

Songster
May 1, 2020
385
881
143
22 miles from the Oz Museum in Kansas
I'm not sure where or not this is a consideration for you, but Pilgrims have a hatch rate of about 55% and Buffs are above 85%. If they're just for you to enjoy I'd recommend buffs. If you want to sell eggs or goslings pilgrims might sell better, but buffs will be easier to hatch successfully.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Top Bottom