Pullets or cockerels?

[JustBabyMargo]

Hi! I have four (2 month old) moss eggers (that we ordered from Alchemist Farms). I’m thinking I have two pullets and two cockerels but I would like some second opinions! So here they are!

Gus- our for sure cockerel!

Logan the chick (used to be Lindy the chick until he grew out his comb and wattles!)- I’m thinking he’s also a cockerel!

Mossy- Our first pullet

Shelly- (She has crossbeak) We think she is also a pullet!

Thanks in advance for any help!

 

[Rhodebar Lover]

Your guesses look to be correct! Crazy comb on the first one! I don't think I've ever seen one quite like that

 

[cherrynberry]

Your correct!

 

[JustBabyMargo]

Your guesses look to be correct! Crazy comb on the first one! I don't think I've ever seen one quite like that

Yeah we could tell he was a cockerel before he was even 5 days old! His comb is just so lumpy but I assume that’s fine? He also has a bent toe (the one all the way to the right)!

 

[InterestingChickens]

2 cockerels and two pullets! The 50/50 spilt.

 

[Rhodebar Lover]

Yeah we could tell he was a cockerel before he was even 5 days old! His comb is just so lumpy but I assume that’s fine? He also has a bent toe (the one all the way to the right)!View attachment 2788120

I wouldn't worry! Likely a hatching defect! He's very unique for sure!

 

[JustBabyMargo]

Thanks everyone for your help! I’m so happy that my Shelly is actually a pullet because she’s my favorite! And I’m hoping to keep Logan the chick (and maybe Gus depending on aggression) because he is so sweet to the girls even now! That’s how my polish rooster started out and he is having the derpiest aggressive stage! But we’re keeping him because he really cares about his girls and when one of my polish girls got “sick” (due to developing her first ever egg) he made sure to keep the other girls (who like to bully her) away and made sure she ate! He’s just the sweetest! He also won’t jump on the girls if they scream at him and only mates 1-3 times in the early morning and then about 1-3 times before bed! So I hope these boys will end up like that! Sorry this is so long! But I really do appreciate everyone’s help!!

 

[Silviaschicks]

You’re correct! And I love Gus’s comb!

 

[JustBabyMargo]

You’re correct! And I love Gus’s comb!

Thank you!! Me too!!

 

[JustBabyMargo]

Just wanted to update:

Gus-

Logan-

Mossy-

And I just want to be completely sure that Shelly is a girl. She likes to make the feeding sound (but all of my polish pullets did that and she’s being raised with new polish pullets who like to do it too)-

Oh and I was also wondering what type of comb Logan’s would be?