Pullets or roo?? Pic heavy!!

Discussion in 'What Breed Or Gender is This?' started by Mk_lanch, Nov 9, 2018.

  1. Mk_lanch

    Mk_lanch In the Brooder

    41
    31
    49
    Sep 20, 2017
    Please can someone give me some idea on what sex my chicks are they are just over 12 weeks old DSC_0879.JPG
    I have one cream Poland(buttons) , one black cream mix Poland(deville) , a white silkie(milky) , a black silkie (carlymero) and a black and brown mix silkie (marmite)....
    Here are the picture
    This is buttons my cream Poland.
    I was thinking girl until today when I was comparing with my other Poland. Also this one is getting picked on heavily by my older girls
    DSC_0879.JPG
     

    Attached Files:

    drumstick diva and maldojas like this.
  2. JedJackson

    JedJackson Free Ranging

    3,267
    6,699
    561
    Jul 6, 2016
    Silkies and Polish are two of the toughest breeds to sex accurately. Clear, close up pictures of the combs would help a great deal. Check for redness at the combs and faces of the Polish. Redness in those areas probably means a cockerel at this stage.

    I'll make guesses without comb pictures, but they could very well be wrong, since they are just guesses.

    Buttons could go either way, but I think it could be a cockerel. Check the comb for redness.

    Deville looks like a pullet to me.

    Calymero looks cockerel-ish to me.

    Milky is looking more like a pullet, but tough to tell.

    Marmite is maybe a cockerel. It has thick legs. Hard to be sure, though.
     
    drumstick diva likes this.
  3. Mk_lanch

    Mk_lanch In the Brooder

    41
    31
    49
    Sep 20, 2017
    hi, thanks for your reply.

    there is no redness or signs of combs yet. ill try and get out and take some close up pictures in a minute.

    carlymero i was leaning towards a pullet as shes so small compared to the others what makes you say cockeral. least friendly of all my chicks aswel. hates being touched or pick up.

    marmite is big so i was thinking he was a cockeral...also from the sounds he makes when i pick him up. he sort of honks similar to a duck
     
    drumstick diva and JedJackson like this.
  4. JedJackson

    JedJackson Free Ranging

    3,267
    6,699
    561
    Jul 6, 2016
    It's mostly just a hunch with Calymero, and hunches are often wrong. Comb size and leg thickness are the things to check with Silkies at that age.

    Buttons could be a pullet. If there is no red at the comb or face, then that is a good sign.

    I don't think you will know for sure on these birds for another month, but getting more opinions from other posters will help a great deal. Just gotta wait for everyone to wake up.
     
    drumstick diva likes this.
  5. Mk_lanch

    Mk_lanch In the Brooder

    41
    31
    49
    Sep 20, 2017
    Here are the close ups. There is a bit of red on buttons but I couldn't get a picture clear enough to show it

    Not the best pictures but I didn't have anyone to help me lol
     

    Attached Files:

    drumstick diva likes this.
  6. Mk_lanch

    Mk_lanch In the Brooder

    41
    31
    49
    Sep 20, 2017
    Im in the uk lol but I know to wait for replies as it's early hours in the US
     
    drumstick diva likes this.
  7. JedJackson

    JedJackson Free Ranging

    3,267
    6,699
    561
    Jul 6, 2016
    I think Buttons is probably a cockerel because of the crest-- I'm seeing longer, pointier feathers there. Not 100% sure, but that's what I think.

    Deville is most likely a pullet.

    Marmite is kind of in between. I'm really not seeing anything that screams cockerel. It's larger than the other Silkies, but the comb isn't too big for it to be a pullet. I think more time is needed to be sure on this one.

    I think Milky is probably a pullet.
     
    drumstick diva likes this.
  8. Mk_lanch

    Mk_lanch In the Brooder

    41
    31
    49
    Sep 20, 2017
    i have an appenzeller cockerel...hes only 17 weeks old...hes a stunning bird...i tried to bond him with my girls and they almost killed him. similar to what their doing to buttons but alot more brutal!
    so hes going to a new home next week and has to be seperate for now.
    but i started to wonder in buttons was a cockerel from the way the girls were ganging up on him and beating him up.
    ill be sad if he is a cockerel as hes the exact colour i wanted and last time i done hatching eggs i got 2 roos both sizzle polands and they were similar colours. i really wanted a girl!
     
    drumstick diva likes this.
  9. Crazy for Chickens!

    Crazy for Chickens! Free Ranging

    6,599
    7,441
    502
    Jun 9, 2017
    N.W. Missouri
    Pullets
     
  10. Mk_lanch

    Mk_lanch In the Brooder

    41
    31
    49
    Sep 20, 2017
    ALL of them?
     
    Crazy for Chickens! likes this.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by: