Starting a new flock. Marans or Welsummers?

Discussion in 'General breed discussions & FAQ' started by TxAg11, Mar 29, 2017.

  1. TxAg11

    TxAg11 Chillin' With My Peeps

    63
    30
    71
    Jan 12, 2016
    Houston, TX
    Several months ago a dog got into my back yard and wiped out most of our flock. Since then we have been fortifying and we are about ready to start anew.

    We had 11 hens in all of various breeds (2 Gold sexlinks, 3 Amer/EE's, 1 Wyandotte, 1 Dominicker, 1 Australorp, 1 Buff Orp, 1 White Brahma, 1 RIR).

    I found that our most prolific layers and best mannered hens were the Ameraucana's and golden sexlinks.
    With our new flock I'm going to stick mostly to gold/black sexlinks (2 of each) and Ameraucana's. I do want 1-2 hens that lays the dark chocolate brown eggs, though. We live in Houston so it can get pretty hot.

    I'm torn between the Copper Maran's and Welsummers. Do y'all have any experience or advice between these two breeds? I'm planning on getting 1-2 dark egg layers, but I just can't decide which breed will do best in our climate. A local breeder carries all varieties, so I'll be starting them all out as 3 mo/ old pullets together.
    Any advice would be most welcome
     
  2. SunHwaKwon

    SunHwaKwon Overrun With Chickens

    4,534
    1,051
    306
    Jul 19, 2015
    Eastern Shore, MD
    I don't have Welsummers, but I do like that you can get Marans in different colors. I have Wheaten, Blue Copper and Splash Copper, and will be adding a Golden Cuckoo eventually. If all he has is Black Copppers then I would go with the Welsummer probably, as I find the black coppers boring looking and perhaps the clean legs of the Welsummer are better in the heat anyway, though I can't say for sure.
     
  3. mcstewartchick

    mcstewartchick Just Hatched

    I just started a new flock and I have two Welsummer chicks and one Cuckoo Maran. I can't speak to the weather hardiness questions and others you have, but I've found that out of those three chicks the Maran is much flightier and a little wacky compared to the Welsummers. They're still very young so time will tell. :)
     
  4. SunHwaKwon

    SunHwaKwon Overrun With Chickens

    4,534
    1,051
    306
    Jul 19, 2015
    Eastern Shore, MD
    Were they from a hatchery or a breeder?
     
  5. KikisGirls

    KikisGirls Be Happy! Read more. Premium Member

    22,379
    19,704
    646
    Jul 31, 2015
    Houston, TX
    My Coop
    My Welsummers are fine in our Heat....and they lay dark eggs....not as dark as a FBCM...but dark enough IMO.
     
  6. sbhkma

    sbhkma Chillin' With My Peeps

    My Welsummers deal with the heat much better than my Cuckoo Marans. Marans do lay lovely dark dark eggs, but they're a bit more flighty and standoffish which, in addition to the lack of heat tolerance, means my next additions will be more Welsummers. I love the breed.
     
    KikisGirls likes this.
  7. Fanci Feathers Marans

    Fanci Feathers Marans Chillin' With My Peeps

    903
    1,521
    231
    Jun 26, 2017
    Missouri
    My Coop
    Excuse you, Marans are fabulous.
    IMG_0072.JPG IMG_9870.JPG DSC_0086_kindlephoto-55377119.jpg received_10206348789357142.jpeg received_10207596246022779.jpeg
     
    KikisGirls and CP Chicken like this.
  8. SOHC-FTW

    SOHC-FTW Chillin' With My Peeps

    988
    299
    146
    Apr 11, 2016
    Fleetwood NC
    I very much liked our welsummers when we had them they were not hatchery stock though they were good quality birds very strong and healthy breed. Our hens were good egg layers mine tended to be a bit shy but the roo "Johnny Cash" was great all around and a good looking fella. No issues with heat up here in the mountains like you get but they made it through our winter months easily. I would choose them over marans but to each their own.
     
    KikisGirls likes this.
  9. sbhkma

    sbhkma Chillin' With My Peeps

    My Wellies come flying to me when I call them, and I haven't spent a bunch of time socializing with them. They treat me like mommy hen. Funny to watch for sure. Very social and curious but not overly friendly. Great foragers and they love scorpions.
     
  10. Fanci Feathers Marans

    Fanci Feathers Marans Chillin' With My Peeps

    903
    1,521
    231
    Jun 26, 2017
    Missouri
    My Coop
    Sound like something Chuck Norris would do. Eat scorpions, that is.
     

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by