What breeds won't mix well with Faverolles, Polish or Buff Orpingtons?

Great list of breeds! The one thing I can contribute is that after raising Polish twice, I've learned that you either need a big space with plenty of hiding spots for hens low on the pecking order to get away from pecking, or you need to get only those hens specifically listed for being super docile. I loved my Polish. They were so sweet and friendly, but they got picked on by everyone. It's hard to raise them through the chick stage without every little adorable puffy topknot feather being gouged out. It's a very sad sight.

An ounce on prevention is worth a pound of cure in this sort of issue for sure. Good luck with whatever you choose!

 

Yes, the Polish can have a hard time of it because their vision isn't as good as the others with all the feathers in their face. You can trim them back around the eyes so that they don't miss "discussion", or keep only the mildest hens.

Your problem girls may come from the EEs, Lakenvelder, Sussex, or Wyandotte. In my flock, the Lakenvelder and the Hamburg rule the roost. Hammie, as pint sized as she is, will run the 9 pound drake Earl off when he gets randy during recess. She'll chest bump that duck all over the yard, and she's still a pullet, not even a hen yet.

Marans and Orps are sweet as pie 9 times out of 10. The others you listed I don't have any direct experience with so I can't tell you how they typically are. For sure go with breeder birds, usually mean birds don't last long in the gene pool like they do at hatcheries. Some of the birds hatcheries don't carry them anyways and you'll be looking for breeders as a source.

 

The only breed I have experience with of the ones you mentioned is orpingtons. They will most likely get along with the other birds, it's just that they might get bossed around.
About the insulation, that will definitely help with regulating the temperature.

 

On your list we currently keep Wyandottes (LOVE) and they are so sweet! My SLWs boss the other birds around but are super sweet to people. The GLWs are super calm and sweet; one is incredibly friendly, the other...meh. Both of the GLWs neither bully or are bullied. ALL the Wyandottes are calm, consistent layers.

My Buff Orps are quiet, easy birds, consistent layers, and sweet though not as friendly as the Wyandottes. They go broody at the drop of a hat and make great moms.

We've had EEs in the past and they fell ALL over the spectrum as far as temperament and where they were on the pecking order. We also had a Delaware who was sweet and calm...never a great layer but the particular bird wasn't terribly thrifty either.

Have fun assembling your chicken family!!

 

Here is western AR instead of buying a pre-fab coop I would look into having someone build one for you. You can probably get a neighbor, church friend etc build one for you much cheaper than buying a pre-fab. In addition you could get them to custom-size for the area of your yard you wanted the coop to set.

 

I know the feeling! Here a few hundred miles north of you, ours does the same thing.

 

We had to separate our two white-crested black polish from the other hens - 2 each of buff orpingtons, black cochins and partridge ameraucanas - because they were so picked on. They were the smallest and they had those crests... the others would sidle up to them, bend down and then start pecking right on their crests. We had to set up a "demilitarized zone" in the run and build them a separate coop.