Which roo to keep?

[Cats Critters]

I only have room for two roos, I have my two adults
Chipmunk:

and Romeo:

Chipmunk is staying, but I'm not a big fan of Romeo, but my little sister loves him

and 4 juveniles, 18wks Monday,but about 15 weeks in Pictures
CM/EE and WL/EE-Kernel (white one)

EE

and the last one I don't have a resent picture of but here is one at about 9wks (WL/EE):

I love Kernel, CM/EE is pretty would be lovely to breed mutts off of but I just don't care that much for him, EE is pretty but I'm not that attached, and WL/EE is pretty and would be fun to breed mutts off of but again not attatched.
Plus I have some chicks under my broodys who look roo but their wild, so If none of them are stunning their going to go.
My dad's cousin is going to take a roo(lost hers) and everyone else would need to find new home or be butchered

So who would you chose?

 

[Country Guy John]

Keep Chipmunk....he looks looks like he will be a good protector of your flock.

 

[Cats Critters]

He is so an less something big happens he is staying but, which other one to keep

 

[Stazia86]

I have a thing for barred rocks, and if i get the chance i will be getting one for my EE girls. what pretty chicks they would make. I say keep chipmunk yes! he's very pretty, and i would personally keep Romeo as a backup. the others move 'em on out!
that's only my opinion, they are you beauties of course, so pick which ones yu feel comfortable with.

 

[Cats Critters]

have a thing for barred rocks, and if i get the chance i will be getting one for my EE girls. what pretty chicks they would make.

Just so you know all chicks from a BR roo will be barred,here is one of mine Pullet EE/BR (have 3 like her but with out muffs and a little skinnier ):

 

[buck431397]

Keep the one you love!!!!!

 

[Happy Chooks]

I vote for Chipmunk and Romeo. (not that it counts for much)

 

[NanaKat]

I'd definitely keep Chipmonk.
The other one I'd keep is your red EE. He is beautiful and will pass on some nice color to hens....and hopefully to their eggs.

 

[Tala]

I had two almost identical RIR roos.....the answer was simple. One bit me all the time, the other didn't.
So me I pick the one with the best personality.

 

[Cats Critters]

Some more added thoughts on some of the roos
Romeo: also is afraid of everything
The 4 Juveniles: are all Chipmunks babies, so their also passing on some of his genes (not hatching any in the near future though, don't have the room)
I'm also trying to think who would be good to give to my dad's cousin (she has 4 what she thinks are WL, hens) and who would be likely to find a home where unless they attack they won't be eaten. Anyone near me is falling in love with Romeo or the Juveniles let me know they might be available!

So far the votes are (and yes they are helping me think):
Chipmunk: 6
Romeo: 2
CM/EE: 0
WL/EE (white): 2
EE: 1
WL/EE: 0