Pros: Winter hardy, dual-purpose, easily adapts to their environment, self reproduces, friendly.
Cons: slow grower, diet, occasionally temperamental.
A great dual purpose breed for the northerner. Our birds are very friendly, with the hens practically underfoot when they see us. They are rather spunky and outgoing and make a great pet for the small backyard chicken enthusiast, and they are also productive enough to be considered good dual-purpose fowl for a small farmer.
Our hens have proven to be excellent layers, but did take 7+ months to mature. We were very surprised how large the eggs were even when the girls were pullets. We do not give our hens a light during the winter but they are still laying very well.
Meat wise the boys grew slowly, but they made up for that in taste. The meat was rather earthy, ironically almost nutty tasting. lol
In diet they aren't as piggish as some breeds we have raised, but they do require a bit of extra protein to grow to their full potential. They do forage well if you want to cut back on the feed bill.
I did mention temperament as a con as well as a pro. Most Buckeye breeders have claimed their roosters to be very friendly, but we had some boys that didn't get this memo. Thankfully, our breeders are very well behaved with humans and their flock mates.
Neither being on the top, or the bottom of the pecking order they easily fit into a mixed flock