I agree they're handsome boys.
I like brown/gold better myself, so I'd be looking at keeping the second bird. But, way before color comes temperament. I don't care how pretty you are, if you threaten me, or are at all disrespectful to a human, or if you're just not nice to the ladies, off...
Hello from another Rachel
Yep, you've got two Easter egger cockerels (young roosters). Sexed pullets are only about 90% accurate, but it looks like you got your Oops and someone else's, also. bummer.