We killed them with a knife and left them there to possibly attract others. This worked I guess, because I found another one in the bucket this morning. I'm leaving it there for the day to attract more. If that doesn't work, I'll try the peanut butter on the can method.
The girls are both 9...
So glad to hear about this. I found 3 mice last night in my 5 gallon bucket I leave in the run. They were hopping up, but couldn't hop high enough to get out. no water needed. I think I'll modify it with the can/peanut butter and trap some more!
My girls are 9 months old and they weren't...