Some roosters are fantastic roosters, they are true flock masters, they keep their girls together, peace in the flock, tidbit, dance, find nests, vigilant awareness for predators. A flock with such a rooster is a pleasure to watch.
A lot of roosters do not come anywhere close to a flock master...
To be honest, let both of these go. Neither one is turning out. There is a REAL possibility of them attacking children. The way to get a good rooster, is not to keep a rotten one. If you want a rooster, wait until most of your pullets are laying. Look around locally, people always have extra...