Puppy attacked chickens - what does this mean??

I read your post....
Sounds like your pup is actually learning but when left to make his own decisions? He got excited and made the wrong ones....

What I do with young dogs is set them up to fail in order to correct the wrong behaviour...Can not learn what has not been taught...
Have him tied up when you can not be with him, or have the birds locked in while your not out...I have a young dog who grabbed my Duck this spring and was swinging him...I corrected that in moments....She does not look at my Ducks no more..She has tried to chase my Chickens but does have good recall and knows sit, lay down and stay...Work on all the basic commands till the dog will do them without hesitation...I still never fully trust her yet, she is turning one next month...
A flighty prey animal and a predator that is young is like fuel to a flame...

I totally believe your dog will not be aggressive, he needs training...

Best of luck

It can take up to 2 years or more to train a puppy enough to trust them completely unsupervised.
Pup is still very young.

I guess setting them to fail as described above so you can catch them in the act and correct them might work.
I prefer to make sure they don't get in a position to get into trouble.

Good advice in above posts. Pup is young, it will take time. This does not mean that the dog will always be aggressive toward your chickens. The trustworthiness will come with maturity. The idea that "once they taste blood they will always be chicken killers" is an old wives' tale. What happened was, your pup found some self-propelled squeaky toys to play with and couldn't resist.

I don't think your puppy will grow up to be aggressive. I'm sincerely not trying to be hard on you, but in my opinion where you went wrong was when the puppy was playing tug of war with the chicken and his toy, and you didn't immediately tell him no and stop it. He saw the chicken as something he was allowed to play with. He might not have even meant to kill a chicken, he might have just tried to play with it. If you've watched puppies playing, I'm sure you've seen how they grab and wrestle each other.
You can definitely train him but I wouldn't let him alone with the chickens for a very long time yet. When we got our first batch of ducks and chickens, we had two dogs, an Aussie mix and a Lab. I knew, from years experience of watching the Aussie chase wild rabbits and small animals, that she had no instinct at all to bite. I've seen rabbits freeze and she stops and waits for them to run again. So I wasn't concerned she would kill a chicken, but knew she'd want to chase them. As for the Lab, she had actually hunted ducks for seven years, so I knew she would gladly kill them if given the chance. Both dogs are completely trustworthy around the flock now and it really wasn't that hard to train them. They both had been taught obedience from a young age though. We kept them on leashes when the birds were free ranging and immediately corrected any over eager behavior. The Lab is very hard headed so it wasn't just a gentle "no no" correction, but a very strong "don't you dare even think about it" which she knows means she will heartily regret disobeying. The day I saw a chicken peck her on the head, and she slunk away without retaliating, I knew she would be okay with them.
Just work on your pup with basic obedience for now. Don't encourage him to interact with the chickens but rather treat them as something off limits.

Hes a puppy, its like having a toddler with teeth.
You never leave them unsupervised, he probably wanted to "play" with the chickens.
Unsupervised, you see the results.

Our dog was over three years old when we got our hens. She was exposed to them via watching them through the fence of the run for months before we let them out in the yard together. After 3 supervised afternoon togehter in the backyard, we had no problems
But shes an adult, not a puppy. I would never leave a puppy unsupervised with chickens.

carlf said:

Hes a puppy, its like having a toddler with teeth.
You never leave them unsupervised, he probably wanted to "play" with the chickens.
Unsupervised, you see the results.

Our dog was over three years old when we got our hens. She was exposed to them via watching them through the fence of the run for months before we let them out in the yard together. After 3 supervised afternoon togehter in the backyard, we had no problems
But shes an adult, not a puppy. I would never leave a puppy unsupervised with chickens.

Click to expand...

And probably already well trained overall too.
Year 3 seems a milestone year....that's the year I see as puppydom being fully complete.

Back the original question, "what does this mean??"

It means that other than when the dog is supervised, you need to keep then separated until the dog is trained and out of the puppy stage.
It does not mean the dog will always see your chickens as chew toys. Just like (most) dogs out-grow chewing up your shoes.
But it does mean you will need to be extra vigilant and work extra hard on training.

I hope it works out, having a dog to watch the chickens is really the best predator deterrent out there.

Thank you for your reply - you made some great points! If nothing else, I hope this was a great learning opportunity for him.

Not hard on me in the least, I honestly expected worse. Without having any experience with chickens, let alone a dog near chickens, I was naive to think I could just wing it day by day. Unfortunately we lost a chicken because of this thinking - I definitely learned my lesson!
I'm pleased to hear of others being cautious with their dogs, even the most trusted dogs, around their chickens. It makes me feel better about my pup and also helps me understand the mistake I made. In other words, its really helpful to know.
Although I have little experience with chickens, I have quite a bit with training dogs. One dog in particular was sharp as a whip. Very well trained and was the most trusted dog I've had the pleasure of working with. Unfortunately, no matter how well trained she was, when a bunny came near she would take off. She was a running dog so once her eyesight caught a bunny in the distance, there was no way to get her to come back or slow down. It was the only thing I could not deter her - so when adopting our new GS puppy I knew I immediately wanted to introduce him to the chickens so he would be used to them and in hopes of not finding them as an exciting critter running around. It was working and he exhibited no signs like my previous dog, I thought I was onto something there. Its too bad but definitely a lesson learned.

Thanks everyone for your feedback. I truly appreciate it!