When I free ranged my chickens I never lost any to predators.. except a crazed dog attack.. but only one was wounded and she recovered.
After the dog attack I built them a coop and run.. and kept them in there..... Then I lost nearly all of them when a mongoose got into the coop and they could not get out to escape!!!!!!! So they were in more danger locked up.. then free ranging.
So now my chickens free range in the day.. and I lock them in a super secure, metal reinforced, predator proof prison at night.
With my ducks it was the opposite way around. Kept in the pen and coop they were always safe. But left to sleep out on the island on the pond a python would eat them... and also yet another crazed dog attack wounded one.. which got a broken wing. Sadly the snake took 6 adult ducks and all the ducklings before I found out what was taking them. The rest of the flock were so miserable being penned up.. I gave them to a friend.
So.. free range, or cooped up.. it all depends on the birds and the situation / environment they are in,, and what kind of predators are about.
After the dog attack I built them a coop and run.. and kept them in there..... Then I lost nearly all of them when a mongoose got into the coop and they could not get out to escape!!!!!!! So they were in more danger locked up.. then free ranging.
So now my chickens free range in the day.. and I lock them in a super secure, metal reinforced, predator proof prison at night.
With my ducks it was the opposite way around. Kept in the pen and coop they were always safe. But left to sleep out on the island on the pond a python would eat them... and also yet another crazed dog attack wounded one.. which got a broken wing. Sadly the snake took 6 adult ducks and all the ducklings before I found out what was taking them. The rest of the flock were so miserable being penned up.. I gave them to a friend.
So.. free range, or cooped up.. it all depends on the birds and the situation / environment they are in,, and what kind of predators are about.