Thanks for the CDC info. It actually makes me LESS worried about carbaryl than previously. That's a document for occupational health, which means it details the exposures for people who work with the chemical for 40+ hours a week. The airborne exposure limits, designed to protect workers at "negligible harm" are actually far higher than many chemicals.CHeck this link out and tell me you feel the same way. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/81-123/pdfs/0100.pdf
http://www.ehow.com/info_8497961_natural-alternatives-sevin-garden.html
http://books.google.com/books?id=nu...v=onepage&q=why was carbaryl invented&f=false
I do not mean to be flippant but I would think that would concern me. I don't know a lot about the stuff such as half life and if it can be built up in cells. I'm sure it can't be all that bad. Have you had any chickens born with deformities or a high instance of chick mortality or egg mortality? When do you think it would be safe to consume eggs or bird meat without consuming the stuff ourselves? Otherwise take it for what it was a suggestion to someone wanting to care for their chickens and not an attack on your morality or ethics. I can;t look in the mirro for you and vice versa. But we can share our love for birds. We can seek out what is the best and not worrying about our own petty little egos.
No, I haven't had ONE SINGLE chick born with deformities. Not even one cross-beak. I consistently get 80-90% hatch rates in a homemade incubator and 100% hatch rates under a broody hen. I consume garden veggies that have been treated with carbaryl after a three-day withholding period, and eggs immediately. I don't "think" when it's safe, I read the literature about withholding periods and KNOW when it's safe.
I didn't read your ehow link. Frankly, giving someone an ehow link is less intellectually rigorous than giving them a wikipedia page.
Quote:
WHOSE ego seems to be on the line here? WHO keeps posting pushing their point of view? I don't own stock in Sevin. I don't care what you use on your birds. Hang a crystal over them, do a chant. However, if a BYCer asks me what to do about mites, I'm going to continue to recommend either a pour-on cattle dewormer like Eprinex or Sevin dust. Because they work and do get rid of an active mite infestation. You may also continue to recommend what you will. Then the BYCer will make up their own minds. That's the beauty of free and open discourse. Of course, it's all a lot more free and open if we refrain from petty little insults.