I've gotten 2 batches of chicks from Ideal Poultry. The first batch of 25 chicks was supposed to be black broilers. Their catalog says the red broilers were supposed to weigh 6 pounds at 7 weeks. Mine barely weighed 4 pounds at 10 weeks. I finally figured out they sent me black stars by mistake. The second batch I ordered from them (I figured I would give them a second chance since they refunded me my money on the first batch) was supposed to be red broilers. Again, the same problem with weight gain. I think they sent me New Hampshire Reds by mistake, but they look so much alike as chicks and adults that I couldn't prove it. As for the health issue, I had a bunch (at least half) of the second batch with crooked toes. Fortunately, I was able to butcher those before it became a mobility issue for them.
I live in Montana and we don't have any hatcheries nearby so I have to mail order my chicks. Personally, though, I'm staying away from Ideal Poultry. Hope this helps.