I don't think one Buckeye rooster would be that noisy. My worst offenders are bantams. They must have a 'little man' complex or something. LOLMy husbands objections for a rooster are due to crowing. We do have 5 acres and are surrounded by people with some acreage, but I don't want annoy other people. If I could get a bird that doesn't crow very loud, that'd be okay. I think I could convince the hubby that we need a rooster eventually.
We won't be getting chickens for awhile. The earliest is next spring, because it will be a learning curve for me and I have two very young children (almost 5 months and 17 months). Until then, I'm learning all I can (from books and this forum).
I like the idea of buckeyes and helping the breed, but I had no idea it would be so complicated! I do not plan in showing chickens at this time, but my kids may want to when they are older.
I'm enjoying the lively discussions on this thread.
I would still encourage a person, especially with young children, to look at birds from a breeder who has been selective for temperament. Buckeyes are supposed to be a calm breed and not produce aggressive roosters, but there can always be an oddball. However, large hatcheries just don't take that step in their breeding program and tend to produce more aggressive birds.
Good luck in your pursuit of being a poultry owner. It sure is enjoyable at whatever your goal of having them is.