I know...I suspect that every "rating" of any hatchery is based on the individuals perception. Mine with Ideal has been good so I say they are good. The bath tub is an excellent idea and it will make a great "pond" for later with a ramp up and down so they don't fall and hurt themselves. Shipping from Cameron, TX to you in New York should be a 2-3 day journey. Probably from Cameron to Dallas then to NY and out on truck/Post Office from there. Just be ready for them like you would with any live bird shipment from anywhere...even near by...and you should do just fine.I'll keep that in mind. I've heard so many negative things and so many good things, its hard to tell what to actually believe. I want to order from them because they don't charge an arm and a leg for shipping plus I can order only a couple of this or a couple of that, I don't have to order a minimum. I was originally going to order from Meyer again but the shipping for just three ducks is 45 dollars and to me that's a little outrageous. I can't even add a couple of chickens or anything to bring the order up to try and lower shipping because Meyer doesn't hatch and ship their own ducks, it's done by their sister hatchery. So I will try Ideal in the spring and place my order probably in February or as soon as they contact me saying the Cayugas are available. I have an old bath tub that is outside that we don't use. I am thinking of lining that with something like puppy pads and using that for a brooder for the ducks in our shed. I figure this way I can fill it with water when they are big enough and it will be easier to clean than the brooder I've used for chicks. I am just hoping that when they ship them everyone makes it safely from Texas to New York.