The big indicator is comb and wattle size and patchiness of color especially on the shoulders!@JedJackson @Rhodebar Lover Thank you for your thoughts!
Number 4 is a strange one for sure. It certainly doesn't appear cockerel like in its behaviour but that comb and wattles screams cockerel I know. I think it will have me wondering for a while, especially when comparing to the colour of the comb of 2 and 5
Is there something else in 4 and Eggbert that you see that make you say only 1 and 3 are pullets?
Not questioning you! Just trying to learn. I really hope 1 and 3 are girls. I love the colouring of the brown one.