Bonus chick ID help, please :)

[Tahai]

This bonus chick came with my Townline order, and I can't figure out what she is. She was 3 weeks, 1 day in these pics.

My order contained Black Australorps, Olive Eggers, Easter Eggers, and GL Wyandottes.

She looks nothing like the 2 australorps in shape and head patterning. She also does not have a single comb.

I thought perhaps an EE, but her legs are black, and no pea comb. Possibly an OE, but again, no pea comb, no feathers on her legs like the 2 known OEs, and she doesn't share a similar head shape with the OEs.

I considered a Black Wyandotte, even though Townline doesn't list them, because she DOES have a flat comb the same as the 4 GL Wyandottes chicks I have. She has black legs, though, and the photos I can find online of Black Wyandottes all have yellow legs.

 

[house1917]

My guess would be OE from a Marans/EE cross. To me that looks like a little pea comb, but her comb close up is a bit blurry. The good news is that it's still very yellow!

 

[Rhodebar Lover]

It has a pea comb and is likely an Olive Egger. I've gotten Easter Eggers from Townline from them years ago and they have the traditional partridge ones and a solid black one would be quite unusual

 

[Tahai]

Thank you. It's the flat comb that threw me, but you are most likely correct and she's an olive egger.

 

[Tstraub]

I’m still very new at this but I think your chick looks more like my jersey giant than my olive eggers. Here is a picture that has my olive eggers and the jersey giant. The 3 front and center are OEs. Behind is my Jersey and GLW.

They look very similar but the jersey has a little longer neck, narrower comb, and black legs. The OEs legs are just a little bit green. Your bird could be an OE but personally I’m leaning more towards JG.

 

[AmeliaBedelia]

I’m still very new at this but I think your chick looks more like my jersey giant than my olive eggers. Here is a picture that has my olive eggers and the jersey giant. The 3 front and center are OEs. Behind is my Jersey and GLW.

They look very similar but the jersey has a little longer neck, narrower comb, and black legs. The OEs legs are just a little bit green. Your bird could be an OE but personally I’m leaning more towards JG. View attachment 3475794

Jersey giants should have a straight comb though?

 

[Tstraub]

Yes single comb for giant. The picture or my eyes aren’t clear enough for me to see the comb well enough to positively tell comb type

 

[AmeliaBedelia]

Yes single comb for giant. The picture or my eyes aren’t clear enough for me to see the comb well enough to positively tell comb type

Yeah, I was going by them saying it was “flat like a wyandotte” to assume it’s not a straight comb…those are usually easily spotted. I didn’t seeeeee anything in the top-down photo, but yeah, the side photo is too blurry to tell for sure. Guess time (or more photos) will tell!

 

[Tahai]

She is still flat combed like the wyandottes, no little pea bumps at all like my other 2 feather-footed OE chicks have. She is 4 weeks today. She is most likely an OE, though, like house 1917 and rhodebar suggested. I'll try to post pics later on when she's grown a bit more.