Every year something new will show up, whether it is off colors, extra toes and nails, split wing, beardlessness, side sprigs, and the list goes on.
While color is important, I think it is better to weed out those with obvious faults first. Then look at the overall conformation, and lastly color. If the birds are equal in form then select for color, otherwise choose the one with better type.
Now which male to keep will depend on your hens. What trait do you want to improve? Better wing carriage? Longer or shorter backs? Higher tailset? You will have to compare them to the hens to see which one would compensate the best for the trait you want to improve.
While color is important, I think it is better to weed out those with obvious faults first. Then look at the overall conformation, and lastly color. If the birds are equal in form then select for color, otherwise choose the one with better type.
Now which male to keep will depend on your hens. What trait do you want to improve? Better wing carriage? Longer or shorter backs? Higher tailset? You will have to compare them to the hens to see which one would compensate the best for the trait you want to improve.
Last edited: