I have a weird looking rooster

[Roger98]

He is a black tail Japanese mixed mutt, I call him Scruffy. I've read and heard that roosters aren't suppose to have colors like he does. And I've had doubts that he's actually even a real rooster at all. He crows, not as often as his brother and it doesnt sound like a normal crow.

This is his brother. A very normal looking rooster right? Seeing the two of them you can probably see why I have speculations. He looks just like his twin sisters, I want to know of anyone else has had roosters that display hen characteristics like this.
(I've been wanting to make a thread about this for a while and I wasn't sure what forum it should go into. My apologies if it's not the right one)

 

[Chick-N-Fun]

Those are 2 handsome fellas!

 

[OhZark Biddies]

Sometimes hens will crow, is it not more likely that he is a she?

 

[Roger98]

Sometimes hens will crow, is it not more likely that he is a she?

He's never laid an egg, but he's also never shown interest in being around/protecting hens.. This is why I have so many confusions.

 

[RoostersAreAwesome]

Was one of the parents hen-feathered? How old?

 

[imnukensc]

Scruffy looks like a pullet/hen to me.

 

[Roger98]

Was one of the parents hen-feathered? How old?

I only know the mother was a black tail Japanese bantam. I got him from my aunt who didn't know who the father was. He's about 8 months old or so.

 

[RoostersAreAwesome]

I only know the mother was a black tail Japanese bantam. I got him from my aunt who didn't know who the father was. He's about 8 months old or so.

The first is a pullet. Could you get a closer picture of the second one's saddle feathers?

 

[Roger98]

The first is a pullet. Could you get a closer picture of the second one's saddle feathers?

These are the closest pictures I have of him at the moment.

 

[FaithVondras987]

It could be a hen who turned into a rooster, it’s a rare thing I looked up