Is it very common to get clean faced birds from a supposedly reputable breeder? Two of my birds (full brothers) are both clean faced. Other than that they are big beautiful boys. They are almost twice the size as the other roosters I hatched out. She only has Ameraucanas, and has her birds separated in breeding pens. (I saw the facilities and her birds first hand). I think I am going to outcross these birds to some of my EE's that are close in color and type to the Ameraucana standard. I know some people may frown upon that. It just seems that these birds are all a little too closely related. They were difficult to hatch and haven't thrived like other breeds I have hatched.
From what I've understood, it has to do with whether the birds had one or two copies of the muff/ beard gene. One copy mated to another one copy, and you will birds with varied muffs, and some with none, but they still carry the muff gene. I believe if you mate them to a hen with really large muffs, all the chicks will have them. Sometimes it is hard to tell how many copies they carry, therefore, it's not too uncommon to get clean faced birds. Hope you chicks get better!!