I ordered from McMurray for my original flock and had a great experience ordering both chicks and starter pullets. This past year I ordered hatching eggs in the spring from My Pet Chicken with great service and products. Just got a shipment of baby chicks this week from My Pet Chicken. Ordering was easy and my chicks showed up happy and healthy.
Do you know how far you are from the hatchery that shipped them? I'm curious because I shipped a "priority mail" package this week and it's going to take four days to reach a location that is reliably two days the rest of the year. I'd like to think they'd give extra attention to a peeping box but IDK. I suspect Amazon is the only customer getting two day service now.